Keeping the whisky flowing
Distilleries need to take all precautions possible to find their way through industry decline and tough times, says Pamela Muir
Whisky has always asked its makers for patience. A spirit that cannot be sold as Scottish Whisky until at least it celebrates its third birthday in a cask, and most “sleeps” for much longer.
For the past decade, that wait was easy to finance because investors, lenders and the public believed demand would keep rising. That belief is now being tested.
Producers are dealing with a decline in global sales, with many cutting output. Trade policy has added to the strain. The welcome removal of the 10 per cent US tariff on Scotch earlier this year came after a long period of lost sales. But relief for exporters doesn’t repair an already stretched balance sheet. Energy, barley, glass, labour and borrowing costs have all risen while a fall in worldwide demand has been exacerbated by increased supply into the market from the recent expansion in production capacity.


Taken together, the effect is a squeeze. Those with heavy debt, little cash and a product that will not be ready for years are the most exposed. The cause is often not bad management, rather the cost of making whisky is paid up front and the revenue arrives much later. As the sector grapples with a new set of challenges, there are good habits distillery owners can focus on to help them weather the storm.
- Most important is a rolling forecast, set against a longer view that shows when the cash runs out if sales do not improve. Distillers know their stock value to the cask. They are often less clear on how many months of fixed costs they can cover.
- Funders respond far better to a plan presented while options remain than to a default notice. Covenant waivers, repayment holidays and restructured facilities are all more achievable before the money has run out.
- Many distilleries have layered finance: bank security, grant clawbacks, cask-ownership schemes, crowdfunded shares, and sometimes a landlord with a different agenda from the business. If a distillery fails, the order in which these claims are met matters enormously. Anyone who has sold casks to private buyers should be sure a buyer holds good title and the casks are identifiable. Poorly documented cask schemes cause serious disputes in insolvency.
- Excise duty, VAT and PAYE arrears are a common route into formal insolvency, and bonded-warehouse obligations need careful handling. Make sure these are current.
- Once a company is insolvent, or heading there, directors must put creditors' interests first. Continuing to trade without proper advice can create personal exposure. Documenting decisions and taking advice early is the best protection.
- A distillery with a sound product and manageable problem may be better served by a refinancing, sale of stock, partnership with a larger producer, or pre-pack sale of the business. Administration isn’t always the end. Often, it is a way of preserving brand, site and jobs. A buyer can take over a viable distillery, and its liquid and reputation survive.
Scotch whisky is not in terminal decline. The 1980s “whisky loch” was followed by consolidation and recovery, and this cycle will end similarly. But the producers who emerge will be those that acted early, with clarity about their finances and sound legal advice behind them. If you are a distillery owner, director, investor or lender, the best time to take advice is before the pressure becomes a crisis.
Pamela Muir is a restructuring and insolvency partner, Thorntons Law LLP